Gas Grill Or Charcoal Grill? Which One Is Better For Your Needs?

Disclaimer: There are affiliate links in this post. At no cost to you, I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Grilling food is a popular summer activity, and people are constantly looking for ways to improve their grilling experience by making it more accessible, convenient, and even delicious. 

If you’re shopping for a grill, you’ve almost certainly encountered both charcoal and gas grills. Everyone has an opinion on charcoal and gas grilling. Which grill type is the best? Is there a correct method for creating incredible grilling recipes?  

Rather than winging it at your next cookout, we’ve compiled a list of the advantages and disadvantages of charcoal and gas grills so you can make an informed decision about which will be the tastiest option of the summer. 

Charcoal grill

The charcoal grill is the original grilling method. These traditional outdoor cookers feature a metal body, with some models made from cast iron or other materials.  

Charcoal grills are fueled with charcoal briquettes and are placed over an open flame to provide heat for cooking.  

Grilling on a charcoal grill imparts unique flavor and texture to foods that can’t be replicated by gas grills, which have more consistent heat distribution and temperature control capabilities. 

A charcoal grill is a classic staple in any backyard. Charcoal grills are easy to use and can be used for a wide variety of foods, such as steaks, hot dogs, or hamburgers.  

A charcoal grill gives you more control over your food because you have to man every part of the cooking process. 

The advantages of Charcoal grill

Charcoal grills typically reach a higher temperature than gas grills. 

When using a grill, at least 600 degrees Fahrenheit is required to get a nice sear on your meat. A kettle grill filled with red-hot charcoals can reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit, so it isn’t a problem. However, even though some gas grills can reach higher temperatures, the cost is usually higher. 

The mouthwatering smoky flavor  

What’s the secret to charcoal grilling’s smoky taste? The higher the temperature, the better. Charcoal grilling has a distinct flavor because the drippings from your meat fall on hot coals and are transformed into flavor-packed steam and smoke that returns to the meat. 

They are more cost-effective 

A basic charcoal grill will cost around $25, while a moderately priced model will cost about $150. Of course, higher-end models cost more, but charcoal grills are significantly less expensive than gas grills, typically costing between $130 and $300. 

The disadvantages of charcoal grills

It requires a longer time to heat up. 

On average, charcoal grills take about 15-20 minutes to reach the proper cooking temperature (not including the time required to light the charcoal). In contrast, gas grills light instantly and get the appropriate cooking temperature in about 10 minutes. Additionally, there are several methods for lighting a charcoal grill. 

The cost of fuel accumulates. 

A 20-pound propane cylinder will last approximately 25 days, whereas a 20-pound bag of charcoal will last only three grilling sessions.  

Additionally, the type of charcoal you use can affect the flavor of your food. A 20-pound bag of clean-burning hardwood/lump charcoal can cost between $35 and $40. 

The cleanup is a little more time-consuming. 

In comparison to a gas grill, which requires only a quick brushing, a charcoal grill must first be emptied of its used ashes before it can be scrubbed. Additionally, follow these grill cleaning tips. 

Gas Grill

Nothing compares to the smoky, charred flavor that a charcoal grill produces. However, if you’re looking to branch out, gas grilling may be worth a try.  

While gas grills have been around for years, their popularity has recently increased as people seek an alternative to the traditional charcoal method.  

There are myriad reasons for the popularity of gas grilling, but what should you know about these grills before deciding which one is best for you? 

The advantages of gas grills

Gas grills are more environmentally friendly and beneficial to you 

This has been demonstrated scientifically! In terms of health, The Healthy advises against using a charcoal grill. Why? Because char-kissed charcoal-grilled meats contain fewer carcinogens. Concerning the environment, research indicates that the carbon footprint of gas grills is approximately one-third that of charcoal grills. 

A gas grill starts up and temperature regulation rapidly 

Your gas grill will ignite with a simple push of the ignition button and a turn of the dial. After a brief preheats, you’ll be ready to grill immediately, rather than waiting for the coals to heat. Additionally, you can transition from the low heat required for a bone-in chicken to the high heat needed for kebobs or steaks without worrying about moving around hot coals. (By the way, here is a comparison of propane and natural gas). 

Versatility 

You can quickly cook delicate foods such as fruit and vegetables without worrying about the smoke flavor imparted by charcoal grilling with a gas grill. We recommend grilling fish and shellfish on a gas grill because you retain the grilled flavor without adding smoke.  

If you desire a smoke flavor, you can easily add a smoke box ($21) or follow these tips to convert your grill into a smoker. 

The disadvantages of gas grills

It takes time for assembly. 

Compared to the easy-to-assemble charcoal grill, a mid-range gas grill requires a little more effort to assemble and connect to a propane tank. 

Safety 

When using a gas grill, you have to be extra cautious, as you should with any other cooking method. Keep your propane tank securely attached, your grill at least 10 feet away from your home, and the grill clean of grease at all times.  

Are you having trouble with grill cleaning? Follow this easy-to-follow grill cleaning checklist, and your grill will look like new! 

Portability 

The towing of a full-sized gas grill to the park or the beach would be prohibitively difficult and dangerous, despite the availability of travel-sized models. 

FAQS

Charring, burning, or grilling meat, poultry, or fish at high temperatures results in heterocyclic amines (HCAs). These HCAs can cause genetic damage, increasing a person’s risk of developing stomach and colorectal cancers. 

These drippings contain fats, oils, sugars, and proteins that vaporize and rise back into the meat they originated. That is how grilling over charcoal imparts its incredible flavor. Briquettes are merely intermediaries, not flavor producers. The more drips you make, the more flavor develops. 

Most people do not consume barbecue food frequently enough to pose a health risk. Even if you spend every Saturday afternoon drinking beer and eating burgers in the sunshine, alcohol, and cholesterol are likely to be more detrimental to your health than HCAs and PAHs. 

Grilling is a healthier alternative to frying. Grilled meats are lower in fat. This is due to the fat dripping off the food as it cooks. Additionally, grilled foods have a lower calorie count than fried foods. 

Whether propane or natural gas, gas grilling is healthier for your body and the environment than charcoal grilling. 

Every three years, the average American replaces their grill. However, routine maintenance and timely repairs can significantly extend that lifespan. According to Business Insider, proper cleaning and care can extend the life of a gas grill by five to fifteen years. 

Conclusion

Choosing a grill can be difficult with so many choices on the market. If you’re shopping for a new grill and want to know which one is right for you, consider what your needs are. If you find yourself grilling year-round, then a charcoal grill might work best for you. However, if summer grilling is more of your thing, gas grills are likely better suited to your needs. 

Gas grills are better for people who have less experience grilling or don’t have much time to spend tending to their meat. They require little effort when cooking and are the best choice for most households. Charcoal offers more flavor than gas, but it’s harder to control and can be a pain if you’re not good with fire. 

There are advantages and disadvantages to both charcoal and gas grills, and only you can decide which is best for your household and way of life. You can’t go wrong with any of the many grilling recipes available this summer. 

Recent Posts
Why Trust Us

You will find what you are looking for at Largo Bar and Grill. From classic to luxury brands, you'll find both. We will help you to select appliances that fit your needs, budget and lifestyle. Whether you want to stop by to learn more — or plan to make a major purchase — we’ll treat you like family and assist you every step of the way. Shop with us today to receive friendly and experienced help along the way.